
Pod Times Square
Best for short stays, theatergoers, and travelers who want a central, efficient Midtown base near Times Square and Port Authority.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Pod Times Square is a compact, design-forward Midtown West hotel focused on efficient, transit-friendly stays. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a storied Upper East Side five-star property for travelers seeking classic luxury and full-service amenities; read this if you’re choosing between a practical Midtown base and a traditional luxury hotel near Central Park.
Updated · about 3.0 km apart

Best for short stays, theatergoers, and travelers who want a central, efficient Midtown base near Times Square and Port Authority.

Best for travelers who want a traditional five-star Upper East Side experience, full-service amenities, and proximity to Central Park and the city’s museum mile.
When Pod Times Square wins: choose Pod if you want small, efficient rooms, direct access to Times Square/Broadway and lots of subway and bus connections at a lower price point and don’t need a spa or pool.
When The Carlyle wins: choose The Carlyle if you value full-service five-star amenities (including a full-service spa), a quieter Upper East Side address, boutique-style rooms and a hotel with strong name recognition and celebrity history.
Bottom line: pick Pod Times Square for compact, practical Midtown convenience; pick The Carlyle for classic five-star Upper East Side luxury and on-site spa and concierge services.
| Category | Pod Times Square | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Modern, compact, efficient city hotel aimed at practical stays | Storied five-star Upper East Side luxury hotel with classic service |
| Location | Midtown West — about 0.4 miles to Times Square and Broadway | Upper East Side — within a 10-minute walk of Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art |
| Size | About 665 guestrooms across multiple floors | 188 guestrooms |
| Check-in / Check-out | Check-in from 3:00 PM; standard check-out around 12:00–1:00 PM | |
| Pools | No pool or hot tub on site | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Serafina in the Sky (rooftop Italian) and Bar 42 lobby bar — 1 restaurant/1 bar on site | 2 restaurants and 1 bar/lounge (including Bemelman's Bar listed among highlights) |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa; small fitness center reported on the 28th floor (confirm availability) | Full-service spa and fitness/health club listed |
| Known for | Compact Pod rooms, rooftop dining and proximity to theaters and transit | Classic luxury, celebrity history, Central Park and museum access |
| Accessibility & family policy | Family-friendly; lead guest must be at least 18 to check in; ADA-accessible rooms available | |
| Parking | No on-site parking; nearby iPark garage one block away | Valet parking (surcharge) listed |
Pod Times Square sits in Midtown West, one block from Port Authority and a short walk to Times Square and Broadway.
Choose Pod for maximum Midtown transit access and proximity to shows and city nightlife.
The Carlyle is on East 76th Street, a short walk from Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Choose The Carlyle for access to museums, Central Park and a more residential, quieter neighborhood.
Pod Times Square focuses on compact 'Pod' rooms that prioritize efficiency and value.
Pick Pod for small, well-designed rooms when you’ll spend most time out exploring the city.
The Carlyle offers a broad range of traditional luxury rooms and suites.
Choose The Carlyle for larger, more fully equipped rooms and a variety of suites.
Pod’s outlets focus on casual rooftop dining and a lively lobby bar.
Pod works if you want quick, casual rooftop dinner and a convenient lobby bar close to theater crowds.
The Carlyle lists multiple dining and bar outlets and is known for its bar/lounge history.
Choose The Carlyle if you want a wider range of on-site dining and a classic hotel bar experience.
Pod’s signature public amenity is rooftop dining and outdoor terrace rather than a pool or spa.
Pod’s rooftop is the main on-site social space; don’t expect a pool or spa.
The Carlyle emphasizes full-service hotel amenities and guest services.
The Carlyle provides more full-service hotel amenities, including an on-site spa.
Pod offers a small fitness center and rooftop nightlife options.
Pod suits travelers who want a basic gym and lively rooftop scene rather than a dedicated spa or wellness program.
The Carlyle offers a full-service spa and quieter evening options such as Bemelman's Bar.
Pick The Carlyle if an on-site spa and a classic hotel-bar atmosphere matter to your trip.

Pod Times Square — steps from Broadway, Port Authority and many subway lines.

The Carlyle — full-service spa, concierge, and traditional luxury service near Central Park.

Pod Times Square — compact Pod rooms and practical amenities for shorter stays and theater trips.

The Carlyle — close walk to the Metropolitan Museum of Art and quieter Upper East Side streets.
Pod Times Square — it’s a short walk to Broadway and positioned for theatergoers; the Carlyle is farther uptown.
The Carlyle lists a full-service spa; Pod Times Square does not have an on-site spa or pool.
Yes. Both properties accept guests of all ages; Pod requires the guest checking in to be at least 18.
The Carlyle — it’s within a short walk of Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Explore how Pod Times Square stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·